Choosing Your Payment Gateway: Stripe vs. PayPal vs. Braintree in 2025

"

Meerako — Dallas, TX experts integrating secure, reliable payment solutions for SaaS and E-commerce.

Introduction

Selecting the right payment gateway is a crucial decision for any online business. It impacts your transaction fees, customer experience, available payment methods, and even the complexity of your integration.

While there are many players, three giants dominate the market for modern web applications: Stripe, PayPal, and Braintree (owned by PayPal).

As a 5.0★ development partner that frequently builds payment integrations, Meerako has worked extensively with all three. This guide provides our comparison based on the factors that matter most to SaaS and E-commerce businesses in 2025.

What You'll Learn

• Key factors to consider when choosing a gateway.
• Stripe: Pros (Developer Focus, SaaS Billing) & Cons.
• PayPal: Pros (Brand Recognition, User Base) & Cons (Developer Experience).
• Braintree: Pros (PayPal + Cards, Flexibility) & Cons.
• Meerako's recommendation for most modern applications.

---

Key Comparison Factors

1. Transaction Fees: What percentage + flat fee do they charge per transaction?
2. Payment Methods: Do they support credit/debit cards, digital wallets (Apple Pay, Google Pay), PayPal, ACH, international methods?
3. Developer Experience (DX): How good are their APIs, documentation, and SDKs?
4. SaaS/Subscription Billing: How robust are their features for handling recurring payments?
5. User Experience: How seamless is the checkout process for your customers?
6. Global Reach: How well do they support international payments and currencies?

1. Stripe: The Developer's Choice

• Overview: Stripe is famous for its "API-first" approach and focus on developer experience. It offers a vast suite of products beyond basic payments (Billing, Connect for marketplaces, Radar for fraud, Terminal for in-person).
• Pros:
  • Best Developer Experience: Clean APIs, excellent documentation, powerful SDKs. Our preferred integration.
  • Excellent SaaS Billing: Stripe Billing is arguably the most flexible and powerful solution for managing complex subscriptions, metered usage, and invoicing.
  • Wide Range of Payment Methods: Cards, wallets, ACH, international options (SEPA, etc.).
  • Highly Customizable UI: Stripe Elements allows you to build a fully custom, embedded payment form.
• Cons:
  • Doesn't offer PayPal payment method directly (though this is changing in some regions).
  • Can sometimes be slightly more expensive than competitors for very basic card processing.

2. PayPal: The Household Name

• Overview: The original online payment giant, instantly recognized and trusted by millions of users worldwide.
• Pros:
  • Massive User Base & Trust: Many users prefer checking out with their PayPal account for convenience and security.
  • Good for Simple E-commerce: Easy to add a "Pay with PayPal" button to almost any site.
  • Strong International Presence: Widely available globally.
• Cons:
  • Clunky Developer Experience: APIs and documentation are generally considered less modern and intuitive than Stripe's.
  • Redirect Heavy: Often requires redirecting users off-site to PayPal to complete payment, which can hurt conversion rates.
  • Less Flexible Subscription Billing: While improving, its subscription features are generally less robust than Stripe Billing.

3. Braintree (A PayPal Service): The Hybrid Approach

• Overview: Acquired by PayPal, Braintree offers a single integration that lets you accept both credit/debit cards and PayPal payments.
• Pros:
  • Best of Both Worlds (Payments): Accept cards directly via Braintree's gateway plus offer the familiar PayPal button.
  • Good Developer Tools: Generally considered to have better APIs and documentation than standard PayPal (though maybe not quite as polished as Stripe).
  • Flexibility: Offers features like its own Vault for securely storing payment methods.
• Cons:
  • More Complex Setup: Integrating both Braintree and PayPal elements can be slightly more involved.
  • Subscription Billing Less Mature: While capable, its subscription features might lag behind Stripe Billing for very complex SaaS models.

Comparison Table (Simplified)

Note: Fees are approximate and subject to change. Always check the latest pricing.

Meerako's Recommendation: Stripe (Usually)

For 90% of the modern SaaS and E-commerce applications we build for our Dallas clients, Meerako recommends Stripe.

Why?

1. Developer Experience: Our engineers can integrate faster and more reliably with Stripe's superior APIs and documentation.
2. SaaS Billing: Stripe Billing is unmatched for the complex subscription logic required by modern value-based pricing models.
3. Flexibility: Stripe Elements allows us to create a seamless, on-site checkout experience that maximizes conversion rates.

While offering a PayPal button (via Braintree or direct PayPal) can sometimes provide a small conversion lift due to user familiarity, we find that Stripe's overall power, flexibility, and developer-friendliness make it the best foundation for most businesses aiming for scale.

Conclusion

Choosing your payment gateway is a critical decision. Stripe offers the best overall package for developers and complex billing scenarios. PayPal provides unparalleled brand recognition. Braintree offers a solid middle ground.

Analyze your specific needs—target audience, business model (SaaS vs. E-commerce), and technical resources—to make the right choice. Or, partner with an expert like Meerako to guide you.

Need help integrating Stripe, PayPal, or Braintree into your application securely?

---

🧠 Meerako — Your Trusted Dallas Technology Partner.

From concept to scale, we deliver world-class SaaS, web, and AI solutions.

📞 Call us at +1 469-336-9968 or 💌 email [email protected] for a free consultation.

Start Your Project →